菲律賓總統杜特爾特與川普的不同之處

正文翻譯

原創翻譯：龍騰網 翻譯：翻譯加工廠 轉載請註明出處

論壇地址：http://www.ltaaa.com/bbs/thread-446301-1-1.html

-------------譯者：百年老軍醫-審核者：哦芒果哦金金------------

The president of the Philippines Rodrigo Duterte has become one of the world』s most notorious politicians.

菲律賓總統羅德里戈·杜特爾特已經成為了世界上最著惡名的政客之一。

He revels in being referred to by nicknames such as "Duterte Harry" "The Punisher" and "The Trump of the East." Outspoken and populist he is best known for his unrelenting and violent war on drugs. But outsiders are confounded by his election and continuing popularity.

他被戲稱為「杜特哈利」 「懲罰者」或 「東方的特朗普」。 作為一個口無忌憚的民粹主義者， 他因他無情而又暴力的反毒品戰爭而出名。 但是他的當選和持續的受歡迎讓外人感到迷惑。

As an anti-establishment figure and political outsider he is frequently compared to Donald Trump.

作為一個反建制派和非專業政客，他總被拿來和特朗普做比較。

-------------譯者：syberrat1-審核者：龍騰翻譯總管------------

But Duterte has not sparked the division associated with his American counterpart. Despite an undoubtedly abrasive character his popularity stretches far and wide. Some of his most fervent supporters are middle-class highly educated urban Filipinos. He does not represent the views of the most dispossessed nor the most marginalized.

但是杜特爾特沒有象他的美國同行，引發分裂。儘管他性格粗魯，但他的聲望卻很高。他最熱心的支持者是城市中受過高等教育、中產階級的菲律賓人 。他的觀點並不是代表無依無靠的貧民和社會邊緣人。

Instead Duterte represents an ever-present brand of Philippine anti-colonialism. In the years immediately preceding Duterte』s election I identified a huge growth in anti-colonial and anti-American sentiments expressed in the mainstream media.

相反，杜特爾特代表的是菲律賓無處不在的反殖民主義烙印。在他當選前的幾年時間裡，我發現在菲律賓主流媒體上反殖民主義和反美思想出現了巨大增長。

These contemporary anti-colonial sentiments have a long and powerful history. The Spanish colonized the Philippines from 1521 and during the mid-18th century resistance spread leading to the first claim of independence in 1898. In the same year however the US purchased the Philippines from the Spanish.

這些當代反殖民主義思潮有著悠久而強大的歷史，西班牙從1521年開始殖民菲律賓直到18世紀中葉，菲律賓人反抗殖民者的鬥爭一直持續到1898年，那年菲律賓首次宣布獨立。同年，美國從西班牙手中買下了菲律賓。

-------------譯者：syberrat1-審核者：龍騰翻譯總管------------

The US was invested in "developing" the Philippines and creating an alliance due to its geographical position as a stepping stone to China. (Indeed the Philippines』 strategic position is the primary reason the US continues to take an interest in the country.) American forms of political legal and educational institutions were implemented and English was taught.

美國投資幫助「發展」菲律賓，並且和菲律賓建立盟友關係，因為其地理位置重要，是通向中國的跳板(事實上，菲律賓的戰略位置是引起美國興趣的主要原因) 。美國模式的政治教育法律機構在菲律賓建立，而且讓菲律賓人學習英語。

Subsequent improvements in health care and education were evident particularly for the middle classes – which led many to accept American control.

隨後改進的衛生保健和教育體系特別明顯是服務於菲律賓中產階段，以便於這些人更好地接受美國的控制。

Protection offered during the World War II occupation of Manila by the Japanese further cemented the US』s position as savior and ally.

第二次世界大戰期間，日本佔領了菲律賓首都馬尼拉，美國向菲律賓提供了保護這進一步鞏固了美國作為救世主和盟友的地位。

-------------譯者：syberrat1-審核者：龍騰翻譯總管------------

The Philippines was formally granted independence in 1946 yet remained closely tied to the US which maintained a large military base there. The US is also one of the major aid donors to the Philippines and has been a primary destination for permanent Filipino migrants.

菲律賓於1946年正式獲得獨立，仍然保持了與美國的緊密聯繫，美國在菲律賓有一個龐大的軍事基地。美國是菲律賓的主要援助國，也是菲律賓移民的主要目的地。

But after the fall of Ferdinand Marcos in 1986 dissent towards the Americans – which had sponsored the dictator』s regime and ultimately gave him protection – grew. This led to theclosure of the military base in 1991. While ruling administrations of the late 1990s supported US influence due to perceived economic and political benefits anti-American and anti-colonial sentiment did not wane among the educated middle classes – those most negatively affected by Marcos and his martial law corruption and imprisonment of detractors.

但是在1986年馬科斯倒台後，出現了針對美國支持獨裁政權並給馬科斯以保護和政治支持的異議，這導致美國1991年關閉了軍事基地。90年代後期菲律賓當局出於經濟和政治利益的考量支持美國對菲律賓的影響力，但是菲律賓受教育的中產階級反美和反殖民主義的情緒並沒有減弱，因為這批人深受馬科斯及其戒嚴令，腐敗和囚禁異見者政策的影響。

評論翻譯

原創翻譯：龍騰網 翻譯：翻譯加工廠 轉載請註明出處

論壇地址：http://www.ltaaa.com/bbs/thread-446301-1-1.html

-------------譯者：百年老軍醫-審核者：龍騰翻譯總管------------

Philius 13 hours ago

"For his part Trump is one of the only Western leaders to support Duterte』s war on drugs. It could be the beginning of an unexpectedly close relationship. But it would be one that risks losing the popular support that put Duterte in power in the first place." Wrong analysis! Quite the contrary Filipinos viewed US positively. It was Barrack Obama"s policy that Filipinos didn"t like/hated most - interference of Philippine internal affairs and his arrogance in imposing his beliefs to Filipino culture. This was met with resentment among Filipinos.

」特朗普詩世界上唯一的幾個支持杜特爾特反毒品戰爭的西方領導人。這有可能成為美菲關係進一步升華的意想不到的開始。 但著也許會成為使杜特爾特失去支持率的威脅。」 這是一個錯誤的分析！ 與這正相反的是， 菲律賓人對美國的看法是正面的。 他們最厭惡的是奧巴馬乾涉菲律賓內部事務的政策和他對菲律賓文化的無禮。大多數菲律賓人都對他感到不滿。

Carlitos 11 hours ago

"..outsiders are confounded by his election and his continuing popularity..." because to put it simply they have no idea about what"s going on in that country and to those who try read about the situation there they read articles like this one which is a propaganda masquerading as journalism. Especially for many americans guys who are so poor at picking out the truth from what they"re reading - which allowed the Russians to manipulate them and end up with a trump in the white house.

「但是他的當選和高支持率讓外人感到迷惑」 因為這些人完全不知道在菲律賓發生了什麼， 而且那些真正想了解情況的人往往只會讀那些由假扮成媒體的宣傳機器所寫出來的文章。 特別是大多數美國人， 他們沒有足夠的智力分辨出他們所讀的文章中的事實－ 這讓俄羅斯人很簡單就控制了他們並將特朗普送入了白宮。

-------------譯者：百年老軍醫-審核者：龍騰翻譯總管------------

MCS 17 hours ago

This writer must have experienced going to the Philippines. He/She has written the truth. Not other journalists who are just waiting for anti-Duterte Filipino journalists reports. Finally I have read an unbiased news about our President. I hope journalists will continue to do their job basing on facts.

這個作者一定去過菲律賓。 他寫出了真相， 這不是一個像其他記者一樣所寫的只是為了反杜特爾特的菲律賓文章。 我終於讀到了一篇對我們總統沒有偏見的文章。我希望記者們會繼續用事實來寫報道。

the brain 13 hours ago

if only we were brave enough to do what duterte is doing --maybe then a huge portion of our nation would have a clear enough head to realize what terrible road the liberal left was attempting to lead us down

如果我們有足夠的勇氣去做杜特爾特所做的事情的話－－ 或許我們國家會有大量的人有足夠清醒的腦袋意識到左派自由主義者正在帶領我們在糟糕之路上越走越衰落。

jig 16 hours ago

Duterte is just applying common sense to bad situations. Dopeheads are like an anchor to any society constantly dragging that society down underwater. At some point our country is going to have to declare war on gangs and drugs as well and bypass the judicial system to solve the problem. Either we will or we will cease to exist. Trump is trying to apply common sense to some bad situations but is opposed by the media and liberals.

杜特爾特只是在用常識來解決糟糕的情況。 吸毒者對於任何社會來說就像一個會持續把大家拉入水中的船錨。 未來我們國家也應該對幫派和毒品發起戰爭，繞過司法系統來解決問題， 不是毒品和幫派死就是我亡。 特朗普只是在使用常識來解決問題但左派自由主義者和媒體在反對。

-------------譯者：syberrat1-審核者：龍騰翻譯總管------------

amber 12 hours ago

Duterte taught us to be proud of ourselves as Filipinos love our country .... work hard love your family establish good relationships with your neighbors;love your countrymen respect the LGBT rights obey our laws be a responsible parent pay your taxes stay away from drugs!

杜特爾特教會我們熱愛自已的國家，為我們是菲律賓人而驕傲。努力工作、愛你的家人、同你的鄰居建立良好的關係，愛你的國人、尊重同性戀的權利、服從法律、成為負責任的父母、繳稅並遠離毒品。

Gloria 16 hours ago

Bigger fingers?

大手指？

StalkingMantis 17 hours ago

Duterte is/was supported 92% of Filipino people.....your daily bashing of Duterte does not count.

杜特爾特在菲律賓人中的支持率高達92%....所以你們每天抨擊杜特爾特也沒用。

marc 15 hours ago

Duterte handed out free T-shirts....Trump charged for them.

杜特爾特發放免費的T恤....川普發放的T恤是要收費的。

-------------譯者：cynics84-審核者：龍騰翻譯總管------------

Patrick 1 minute ago

The only only people that consider what Duterte is doing is a human right issue are the drug addicts and pushers alike. The media did not report that he gave all the people involved with drugs a choice.....either go and get rehabbed or risk being killed. He wants to eliminate a major scourge in the Phillipines that most of the popluation wants gone. The people know he wants the best for the country. It is a simlar comparison to Trump. Whether the media will ever understand that most of Trump"s policies are for the good of the US if they would just let him operate with some sort of decency you will probably be surprised at what gets accomplished. But Trump is his own worst enemy. The really only difference between the two is Trumps ego which must be stroked every day. Mostly by himself..

Patrick

只有吸毒的和販毒的才認為杜爾特政策會有人權問題。媒體並沒有報道但其實老杜給了這些人選擇——戒毒或者被殺。老杜只是想清除的販毒這個毒瘤，這也是廣大菲律賓人民熱切期盼的，人們知道老杜其實是為了國家好。這點和特朗普相似，也許媒體永遠無法明白，大部分特朗普的政策都是對美國有益的。如果媒體能給特朗普點面子，讓他自由施展，那他一定會做出令人驚訝的成就。當然，特朗普最大的敵人就是自己。老杜和特朗普的唯一區別就是特朗普的自尊每天都需要被擼的亮亮的，這一點絕大多數情況特朗普親力親為。

-------------譯者：后羿A射日-審核者：龍騰翻譯總管------------

Mike 22 minutes ago

The author missed the point completely . The Colonial period had very little to do with the current situation in the Philippines . The Philippines is seeing unbelievable economic growth . A rising middle class is tired of the status quo and wants action ....in steps Duterte . Though Duterte has talked about the Colonial period the real issue for him is Obama"s arrogance and lack of respect for the Philippines and it"s people . Duterte is all about fixing the many problems facing his country and drugs is a major issue . The US could have stepped in and helped him even more but instead gave him lectures about how to run the Philippines ...thanks Obama . I live in the Philippines and Obama was so insulting as well as belittling to the country during his term of office . Make no mistake about it ....Obama cost of a key ally that will be hard to win back . In general people in the Philippines are very much in favor of the US but when you insult them that"s puts a different twist on the politics .

作者完全沒有抓住要領。菲律賓的殖民時期對現在的菲律賓影響很小。現在菲律賓經濟增長速度驚人。興起的中產階級對現狀不滿，他們想要改變，所以杜特爾特就當選了。雖然杜特爾特也談到過殖民時期，但是他真正在意的是奧巴馬的傲慢以及對菲律賓和菲律賓人們的不尊重。杜特爾特正在全面解決這個國家遇到的問題，當然毒品是最主要的。美國原可以介入甚至提供幫助的，然而美國卻是站在一旁，對他的政策指手畫腳。感謝奧巴馬。我生活中菲律賓，我能感受到奧巴馬當政時期對這個國家的侮辱和輕視。毫無疑問，奧巴馬失去了一個關鍵的盟友。失去了的就很難再爭取回來了。總之，菲律賓人民是很喜歡美國的，但是如果你羞辱了喜歡你的人民，那麼他們就會在政治上站到你的對立面。

-------------譯者：syberrat1-審核者：龍騰翻譯總管------------

robert 1 hour ago

The only thing separating these two ignorant bullies and worse is 8356 miles.

唯一分開這兩個蠢貨惡霸的東西就是兩國之間的那8356英里距離。

Mart 1 hour ago

One of the very few more accurate assessment of what is currently happening in the Philippines. I congratulate the author.

對目前發生在菲律賓的事情進行準確評估的少數人之一，我贊同作者的觀點。

Eric 14 hours ago

The character and personality may be similar. Both are bully. Duterte may made it clear that he is doing something for the good of the country. That is why people still support him. Trump on the other hand does not have any idea what he is doing except for enriching himself and his family.Trump may also destroy the American structure of government. Duterte may think of becoming a dictator but I doubt he"ll make it. Of the two Trump is a real con man the other is an ideologue.

這兩人性格相似，都是惡霸。杜特爾特清楚如何為了國家利益而行事，這也是為什麼人民支持他。另一方面，川普除了讓自已和自已的家人更加富有以外，不知道該做什麼。川普可能摧毀美國政府結構，杜特爾特可能想成為一個獨裁者，但是否能成功，我很懷疑。這兩個寶寶，一個是真正的騙子，另一個是理論家。

喜歡這篇文章嗎？立刻分享出去讓更多人知道吧！